3 reasons why you need to ditch valet parking

July 3, 2024

TABLE OF CONTENTS

In theory, valet parking seems like a luxury amenity. Or it may seem like the perfect solution to a parking shortage at your property. But in reality, it’s more of a hassle than it’s worth.

In fact, it may be a massive turn-off for potential residents. Take it from this one Reddit user who really wanted to move into an apartment but was worried that the only parking available was valet. He took to Reddit to ask for advice:

Many residents strongly dislike valet parking. But what about property management? In this post, we decided to investigate this from the property manager perspective. After talking to a handful of property managers, we came to the same conclusion: You should ditch your valet parking. Here are the top three reasons why.

It’s prohibitively expensive

This was the most salient reason that property managers voiced for ditching their valet parking. 

There are several direct costs associated with valet. Jeremy Wolfset from 201 Isabella recalled that valet was “prohibitively expensive.”

“We were spending over $100,000 per year between the costs of the valet company and the salary/benefits for the single attendant.” 

Volkan Pakis from Sentral Union Station shared a similar story. 

“Some months, we paid over $35,000 for valet. At the end of the year, all of the revenue we got from parking was eaten up by valet costs.”

On top of paying parking attendants or valet companies, you also have to factor in insurance. In California, for example, valet insurance costs about $50-80 per vehicle you’re moving every month. At large properties, this number can add up very quickly. 

There are some indirect costs as well, such as increased time spent by management having to deal with valet-related issues or responding to resident complaints. Not to mention the time and money that goes towards handling property damage claims. 

Several property managers have stressed to us that valet can often be a poor investment. It's expensive without boosting parking revenue, providing very little ROI for properties.

It’s inconvenient for residents

Despite valet’s designation as a “luxury amenity,” residents are typically not as thrilled with it as you might think

One person on the aforementioned Reddit thread summed it up well: “That’s not a luxury to me, that’s a major headache.” 

When residents have to depend on notifying valet at least 15 minutes before they need to access their car, it can inconvenience them and restrict their ability to head out on short notice. Imagine running late for work only to have to sit and wait for your car to be delivered to you. (Stackers are similarly inconvenient for this reason.)

These problems can be exacerbated during peak hours like the beginning or end of the work day. These bottlenecks are likely to happen, and residents’ patience will quickly be worn thin. 

Volkan from Sentral Union Station experienced this problem constantly. “At rush times, we really needed 2 valet attendants for things to move smoothly, but we could only afford one. So there were always backups.”

Putting their car in the valet's hands can also cause some paranoia for a resident. Since valet is often used as a solution to tight parking areas (and residents know this), people may worry that their car is going to get dinged at some point.

And these fears aren’t unfounded. As Volkan shared with us:

“Every other month, someone submitted a claim with damage to their vehicle.”

There are other small inconveniences that can frustrate residents and distract from the overall luxury quality of their experience, like having to adjust seats and mirrors every time they get their car from valet. 

Operationally, it’s complicated

The ideal valet parking scenario often doesn’t play out in real life, because it’s usually not as well-oiled of a machine as it should be. Stacking cars to fit more in a smaller area might seem ideal, but it can quickly turn into chaos when not managed well. 

At Sentral Union Station, valet was operated using a manual whiteboard system, leading to a lot of human error and inefficiency. For properties looking to squeeze in more spots, our findings suggest that they will rarely be able to fix the problem with valet.

Jeremy told us, “We could never see the boost in utilization that we were hoping for from valet.” 

Due to the high cost of valet attendants, many properties are only able to employ one person, which leads to consistent difficulties. If your one attendant is on a break, people don’t have access to their cars during that time. 

Due to valet operations often being separate from the rest of the operations at the property, breakdowns in communication can often occur. Too often, communication can turn into a game of telephone as messages are passed among residents, property management, and valet. And since resident communication is one of the most critical pieces of a healthy property management strategy, this can cause some serious issues. 

Valet parking isn’t the answer… so what is?

We know that sometimes, not having enough parking to accommodate your residents and their guests can make you feel like you’re backed into a corner and valet is your only option. But more often than not, implementing valet is only going to introduce more problems and may not even solve your original problem in the first place. 

More and more properties are removing valet and looking to technology instead. Self-serve resident parking solutions like Parkade are tailor-made to ease parking shortages, boost resident satisfaction, and increase overall building revenue, all while reducing operational load on staff. 

Using a parking management solution like Parkade can help you modernize enforcement, better utilize empty spots with short-term leases, and leverage revenue management for parking.

Jeremy shared with us the change he experienced when he made the change from valet to Parkade:

“Our parking utilization is always at 100% now, which we were never able to get to with valet, no matter how hard we tried.” 

Technology has a much higher return on investment than a valet service, too. Between increased revenue from better parking utilization, sophisticated pricing, and cost savings from streamlined parking operations, you’re improving your parking situation in multiple ways.

Want to see how Parkade works, and how it can make the decision to ditch your valet the easiest decision to make? Check out this interactive infographic to see how many of your problems it can solve.

Follow us on social:

More from the Blog

Expert advice on making the transition from bundled to paid parking

With a little strategic change management, you can minimize the hiccups and get more residents to buy-in to the value of paid parking more quickly.

Read Story
Out-of-the-box strategies to boost occupancy in uncertain markets

Market conditions greatly affect property managers and owners. We've culled together a few unique strategies to weather the storm during uncertain periods.

Read Story
How to calculate and improve NOI at multi-family properties

Every property manager or real estate owner has strategies for increasing revenue – but that's only one side of the story. Read on to discover how to calculate NOI, a crucial number for measuring profitability.

Read Story

Want to learn more about Parkade?

UNLOCK THIS POST

Want to keep reading?

Almost there!

Success! Your content will unlock momentarily.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
BlogParking Management Software ROI

Investigating the ROI of parking management software

With parking being one of the largest drivers of ancillary revenue at multi-family properties, it's imperative to get it right. But just how much return can you expect from parking management software? Read on to find out.

Published: August 7, 2024
Hannah Michelle Lambert
Content Writer

Boosting ancillary revenue is often a major focus for property managers and owners alike.

Especially given that the baseline forecast for rent growth is slightly lower this year than average (2.5% versus 2.9%), properties are increasingly looking for ways to raise their bottom line without compromising the quality of living for their residents. 

One often overlooked but significant opportunity lies in parking. If managed well, it’s a potential treasure trove for additional revenue. But that’s only if it’s done well. 

Parking tends to be one of the biggest thorns in the side of a property manager. Because traditional systems — like spreadsheets and rentable items — are not built to handle tenant parking efficiently, teams aren't able to reap the full benefits parking has to offer as an ancillary revenue source. As soon as a team makes the decision to invest in a proper parking management system, the benefits often more than pay for themselves.

In this guide, we will explore those benefits, touching on both the financial and operational upside of a solid parking management strategy.

We’ve combed the data from all of our clients to identify the exact numbers to prove that there truly is ROI in parking management systems like Parkade. 

Understanding parking management

Before we dive into the numbers, let’s first establish a baseline of what exactly parking management entails. As any property manager will tell you, it involves much more than just hanging a tag on a resident’s car and calling it a day.

The key components of a parking management system are:

  • A system of record to track parking assignments, lease lengths, vehicle details, and parking prices, ideally integrated with your PMS.
  • An enforcement strategy that ensures parking rules are clear and establishes consequences (typically fines or towing) when someone breaks them.
  • A method to pay for parking, whether it’s bundled in with rent (which we don’t recommend) or paid for in a separate system.
  • A self-serve system for residents and guests to book long or short-term parking. 
  • If there is a gate on the property, provisioning and deprovisioning of gate entry should also be considered in the parking management strategy. 

The old-school way of addressing these needs isn’t cutting it anymore. Many properties are still using manual processes, like an Excel spreadsheet, rentable items, or even a physical piece of paper to keep track of their parking. 

And far too often, properties are relying too heavily on staff members to handle parking matters that take up a significant amount of time, like enforcement or guest parking.

Moreover, there’s one point that just can’t be ignored: If you’re still using old-school parking management systems like spreadsheets and rentable items, you’re leaving money on the table. 

So the parking management we’re discussing here that delivers positive ROI is a technology-led solution that automates all aspects of parking operations, improves resident experience, and unlocks new revenue streams.

Setting the stage: Residents value good parking

Delivering on resident expectations should be a main priority for any multifamily property, and parking is one area of the resident experience that is especially critical to consider here. 

65% of property managers cite parking as a top concern among residents. Whether it’s for existing residents or prospective residents, providing a simple, reliable, and flexible parking solution has a direct impact on the success of your property. 

Part of this is due to reputation. Properties have reported a 44% increase in their reputation scores after fixing their parking problems. And this boost in a reputation score can trickle into several different areas, boosting not only the number of new residents, but also leading to more renewals from existing residents.

But we know you want the hard dollar amounts, so let’s talk more about some real-world outcomes that Parkade's parking management software delivers. 

So, what do the numbers say about the ROI of parking management software?

Long-term net parking revenue for stabilized buildings

Once properties implement a system to help them optimize pricing and management of long-term parking, they see immediate gains in their long-term parking revenue. The average 6-month increase in net long-term parking revenue for the cohort of 7 properties we sampled was 24%, translating into thousands of extra dollars. 

Long-term net parking revenue for lease-ups

Better parking management also empowers properties to far outperform their projected revenue from long-term parking when they’re in the lease-up phase. 

On average, properties from the cohort we sampled estimated that they would bring in $15,925 on average from long-term parking revenue per month. But thanks to Parkade helping them optimize their parking strategy, better enforce their parking rules, and keep a better record of who is parking where, the average revenue from long-term parking was $23,450 on average, which is a 47.3% increase from the estimates in their pro forma. 

Total net parking revenue for stabilized buildings

For buildings that are already at full occupancy, the average increase in parking revenue sits at 31% once they implement Parkade’s parking management solution. 

Revenue metrics for lease-ups

The best time to implement new parking management systems is at the inception of the building. Getting parking right from the beginning ensures that you are maximizing total parking revenue from day one, as well as establishing a positive reputation around parking. Many properties underestimate the revenue from long-term parking and may often leave out potential short-term parking revenue altogether. 

When a few properties we worked with during this phase were estimating parking revenue at the start of their lease-up, they estimated around $35,000 on average. But the results, since they decided to go with Parkade right from the start, blew those numbers out of the water. In reality, they were able to bring in closer to $58,000 on average, which is a 66% increase from the estimates.

Short-term parking: An opportunity

The boost in revenue continues to be apparent when you zoom out to look at short-term parking, too. Short-term guest parking can be one of the most underutilized revenue streams, and represents a huge opportunity for multi-family properties to tap into. However, it's historically been very difficult or impossible for properties to see this revenue without parking management software that automates the process.

Especially in popular areas, like city centers or near shopping malls and sporting arenas, there’s often a high demand for short-term parking. When properties put a system in place to monetize this guest parking, they can unlock hundreds or even thousands of extra dollars per month. 

Automating guest parking

Without a good system in place to manage parking, many properties often leave guest parking as a free-for-all (meaning they don’t make money from it), or if they do attempt to monetize guest parking, it turns into a massive beast to handle. 

Erica, a property manager at Thrive Properties, told us about her pre-Parkade experience with guest parking, preventing them from delivering on a key resident need: “There was no world where we were doing short-term parking by the hour or even by the day because there was just no way to manage that.”

If you have a complicated or inconvenient system for guests to reserve parking, especially one where they have to walk into the office during office hours, guests are often more likely to try to get away with not paying for parking. (And if you don’t have a great system to enforce parking, they may very well get away with it).

With the right parking system, you’re able to give guests a flexible, 24/7 solution, removing any previous barriers that may have caused them to break the rules out of convenience. 
Maximizing guest parking availability

Another way that manual parking management may stand in the way of effectively monetizing guest parking is the inability to accurately track how many spots you have available for guests to reserve in the first place. 

Taylor, the property manager at Strata and Venue, shared her experience of desperately needing more guest parking and discovering they had a full 50 more open spots than they thought. 

“We actually had way more spots that we could have used for guest parking, but we didn’t know that because of the way we were using our parking system. Not to mention, we wouldn’t have the system to leverage them without a Parkade.”

When your parking management system gives you an accurate, real-time view of available spots, you can leverage guest parking to its full capacity.

Utilizing idle parking spots

A reliable parking-management system also allows you to make the most use of every single spot available. With technology that uses smart inventory management, properties can release idle or unassigned parking spots into the system for short-term use. So spots that would have otherwise been sitting empty between leases can suddenly be leveraged as an extra revenue-generating spot in the meantime. 

Net revenue for short-term guest parking

When properties have a great system to implement paid guest parking, without putting too much strain on their staff, they immediately see a boost in revenue.

They’re able to turn an operation that was perhaps bringing in no money — or some revenue, perhaps at the expense of staff time —  into a significant revenue source with little-to-no staff involvement. 

On average, Parkade customers experience a 303% increase in their guest parking revenue after Parkade fees. And there were some properties that saw almost a 400% increase.

Opex (operational expenses) savings

When handled manually, parking management can steal hours from on-site property management teams every week. Between fielding requests or complaints from residents, tracking down parking records, walking the lot to enforce rules, handling guest parking, and manually inputting rentable items, parking can quickly balloon into one of the most time-consuming tasks for staff.

Parking management software can automate away a lot of the most tedious aspects. For example, Parkade gives residents self-service access to reserve and pay for parking (while allowing for any rule sets the property wants to enforce), provides hands-off enforcement support, and even automates gate access via the app so that teams don’t have to worry about distributing or replacing clickers. 

Properties have seen that the time teams no longer spend on parking leads to a direct decrease in operational expenses. As a result, they can redistribute those team members' time to more meaningful tasks.

On average, we’ve seen properties decrease their operational expenses by $60,000-$100,000 from savings on parking operations alone. This means that they were able to save what’s equal to a full-time employee’s salary. 

Annual NOI improvement

All of the revenue metrics mentioned up until this point have been after Parkade's fees. 

When you roll everything up together — both the increase in revenue (after fees) and the opex savings — investing in parking management software has an incredibly positive impact on annual Net Operating Income (NOI).

Whether teams are looking to calculate their property value, secure financing, make operational decisions, or pitch to investors, NOI is one of the most critical numbers to boost. 

By coming at NOI from both sides, in terms of opex savings and revenue generation, parking management technology is extremely low-hanging fruit when it comes to boosting NOI. 

At the Parkade properties we surveyed, teams saw anywhere from a $66,000 to $126,000 improvement to their net operating income from parking alone. 

While parking may not seem like it deserves to be the biggest priority for many properties, the numbers tell a different story. By investing in a proper parking solution, properties are able to significantly improve upon all of their business goals, whether it’s boosting revenue, streamlining operations, improving resident experience, or all of the above. 

About Parkade

Parkade is the #1 parking management software for multi-family buildings. With our resident-facing app and staff dashboard, parking runs itself. Your team will boost revenue, reduce time spent on parking, and improve experience for residents and guests, all without lifting a finger.

Explore our features below, built for communities just like yours.

Ready to transform parking?

Ready to optimize your parking operations and start seeing the immediate ROI?

Reach out to schedule a demo now.

What are you waiting for?